The feat marks the first such entry by Wrexham AFC since the 1981-82 season.
Per theAssociated Press, the raucous audience responded in tandem, lighting flares and proudly waving flags.
Watch on Deadline
It just seemed like an impossible dream, Reynolds told the AP afterward.
Blake Lively, Rob McElhenney and Ryan Reynolds after Wrexham’s victory on April 26Getty Images
We said five years ago our goal was to make it to the Premier League.